In short
- Physical products sell for about five times more per item: a $23.03 median across 1,644 physical searches against $4.84 across 266 digital ones.
- Digital products cost nothing to stock or ship, and their pages turn over faster: 66 of the top 100 "printable games" results were new.
- Gift searches are the most open of the big categories: 44 of the top 100 "gift for her" results were listed in the last 30 days.
- Every broad category is crowded ("home decor" returns 40,491,934 listings). About four in ten specific searches had under 10,000.
- For a first shop, pick the format by what you can produce every week, then narrow the search until the listing count is small.
On this page
There is no single best thing to sell on Etsy, but the choice is not a guess either. Each category has a price level, a level of competition and a rate at which new listings reach page one, and all three can be read from Etsy's live search. We measured 29 broad product searches and the wider market around them between 1 October and 22 November 2026.
How we measured
We used Optimsy's Goldmine, which reads Etsy's live search results for a phrase. For each search:
Listings is Etsy's own count of active listings.
Median price and new of 100 come from the top 100 results. "New" means first listed in the last 30 days.
Digital share is how many of those top results are digital downloads rather than shipped items.
The price and competition comparisons between physical and digital come from 2,432 searches measured with Goldmine between 22 October and 22 November 2026. These are searches sellers chose to measure, not a random sample of Etsy.
Etsy does not publish sales, so nothing below is a sales figure. It tells you what a category costs to enter and what a sale in it is worth.
The numbers
Format: listings · median price · new of 100.
Home and wall
home decor: 40,491,934 · $14.25 · 10 new
wall decor: 26,125,428 · $119.97 · 28 new
wall art: 23,548,357 · $64.48 · 14 new
art print: 16,183,748 · $27.23 · 16 new
Gifts
gift for her: 10,669,910 · $42.50 · 44 new
personalized gift: 10,225,208 · $18.73 · 17 new
wedding gift: 6,920,733 · $7.61 · 8 new
baby gift: 4,685,474 · $11.04 · 3 new
gift for him: 3,439,366 · $25.48 · 13 new
teacher gift: 1,911,764 · $8.43 · 14 new
Things you make or print
t shirt: 11,088,253 · $27.99 · 10 new
necklace: 6,472,636 · $36.45 · 14 new
christmas ornament: 2,161,453 · $19.99 · 29 new
ceramic mug: 1,505,733 · $20.69 · 37 new
phone case: 772,100 · $27.00 · 11 new
Digital downloads
digital download: 11,057,454 · $4.20 · 15 new
digital paper: 6,744,336 · $4.29 · 29 new
printable wall art: 3,538,040 · $5.07 · 12 new
canva template: 1,849,848 · $5.34 · 28 new
crochet pattern: 1,015,956 · $5.99 · 26 new
printable planner: 934,101 · $4.35 · 51 new
digital planner: 848,685 · $6.46 · 41 new
wedding invitation: 812,436 · $9.17 · 22 new
printable games: 789,787 · $6.99 · 66 new
wedding template: 789,263 · $12.36 · 28 new
digital stickers: 590,699 · $3.99 · 32 new
coloring pages: 540,659 · $2.99 · 23 new
seamless pattern: 473,876 · $4.51 · 24 new
coloring book pdf: 199,827 · $3.99 · 75 new
Physical or digital: the real trade
Across the wider set of searches, physical products had a median price of $23.03 (half fell between $18.99 and $35.08). Digital products had $4.84 (half between $3.99 and $5.69).
Competition was about the same. The median physical search had 19,374 listings and the median digital search 23,264. So the choice is not "which is less crowded". It is this:
Physical: more money per sale, but materials, making time, packing and shipping on every order. Your output is limited by your hands.
Digital: a few dollars per sale, but no stock and no shipping, and one file sells any number of times. Your output is limited by how many good files you can list.
A beginner with no workshop usually starts digital because the first sale costs nothing to fulfil. A maker who already produces something starts physical because the product exists. If you lean digital, we measured the product families separately in digital products to sell in 2026.
Where new shops get seen
The new-of-100 figure shows how much of page one goes to recent listings.
Fast pages: coloring book pdf (75 new), printable games (66), printable planner (51), gift for her (44), digital planner (41), ceramic mug (37). New listings reach buyers quickly here. They are also pushed out quickly, so these categories suit sellers who can release regularly.
Slow pages: baby gift (3 new), wedding gift (8), home decor (10), t shirt (10), phone case (11). Established listings hold the top. Entering takes a clear difference, not another similar item.
Gifts stand out among the big categories. "Gift for her" has over ten million listings, a $42.50 median and 44 new results in the top 100: high price and an open page at once. The work is in choosing who "her" is. "Gift for her" is not a product; a specific gift for a specific person is.
Price follows the occasion
The highest digital price on the list is "wedding template" at $12.36, and "wedding invitation" sits at $9.17. Most other digital searches are between $2.99 and $6.99. Buyers pay more when the purchase is tied to an event with a date.
The same holds for physical items: "gift for her" ($42.50) and "necklace" ($36.45) are above the $23.03 physical median. If you can attach your product to an occasion (a wedding, a new baby, a teacher's last day), you are usually selling into a higher price band than the same item sold as decoration.
Every broad search is crowded; specific ones are not
No category above has fewer than 199,827 listings. That does not mean there is no room. In the wider set, 677 of 1,644 physical searches and 91 of 266 digital searches had under 10,000 listings: about four in ten and one in three.
The difference is one or two extra words. "Coloring pages" returns 540,659 listings. Add a theme and it drops into the thousands. The category tells you the price band; the narrow version is what you actually list for. We list 20 measured examples in Etsy niches with low competition.
How to choose your first product
Start from what you can make every week. A shop needs many listings. Pick the format you can keep producing, not the one with the best single number.
Pick a buyer and an occasion. They set the price band more than the product type does.
Narrow the search. Add a theme, an audience or an occasion until the listing count is under about 10,000.
Check that the page admits newcomers. A few new results in the top 100 is healthy. None means the top is locked.
Measure the exact phrase before you make it. Goldmine reads the live listing count, median price and new-listing share for any search, so you can compare three ideas in a few minutes.
If you go digital, the files themselves are the quick part: Optimsy's studios make printable wall art, seamless patterns, coloring books and clipart sets, and write the listing. If you go physical, the listing photos are where most of the time goes.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best thing to sell on Etsy for beginners?
Something you can produce repeatedly in a narrow niche. Digital downloads are the easiest start because there is no stock or shipping, but they sell for about $5 each. Physical products had a $23.03 median in our measurement and need materials and fulfilment. Choose by what you can keep making.
What sells the most on Etsy?
Etsy does not publish sales by category. By listing count, the largest searches we measured were home decor (40,491,934 listings), wall decor (26,125,428) and wall art (23,548,357). Large means popular with sellers as well as buyers; the narrower versions of these are where a new shop competes.
Is it better to sell digital or physical products on Etsy?
Neither is less crowded: the median physical search had 19,374 listings and the median digital search 23,264. Physical earns more per sale ($23.03 against $4.84 at the median) but costs time and materials on every order. Digital earns less per sale and can be sold without limit.
What can I sell on Etsy without making anything by hand?
Digital downloads: printable wall art, planners, templates, digital paper, coloring pages and clipart. They are files the buyer downloads, so there is nothing to ship. Etsy requires the work to be your own and asks you to disclose in the listing description if AI was used to make it.
References
Check the niche before you make anything
Goldmine scans categories and scores rising niches with growth and competition context.
Try GoldmineFree to sign up
Is your listing ready for search?
Paste your title and tags; it flags duplicates, tags over 20 characters and empty tag slots.
Open the Listing CheckerNo sign-up needed
Emirhan Sevim
Co-founder of Optimsy. Builds tools that help Etsy sellers make listing, pricing and niche decisions with data.
About Optimsy →